• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Random Dynamic Resources Ltd

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us

      Random Dynamic Resources is a frontline market research company providing field research services across Africa. We develop field research tools that enhance productivity and optimize market research values via the use of up to date consumer– oriented technology, in–built strict quality control … Continue reading... about About Us

  • Methodologies
    • Quantitative
    • Qualitative
    • Quality Strategy
    • Data Management and Analytics
  • Our Reach
    • Our Reach

      We have explored most urban and rural communities across the Sub Saharan Africa with diverse local languages and rich cultures: we make use of local staff in each country we fieldwork to bring about the best approach. In Extreme difficult environment, we strive for improvement while learning new … Continue reading... about Our Reach

  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Blogs
    • Webinars
    • Related Links
  • Careers
    • Careers

      If working with a team of highly successful people who are making a positive difference in our business and our community ranks topmost in your mind, look no further as Random Dynamic Resources Ltd. offers you an exceptional career opportunity to achieve great things! At Random Dynamic Resources … Continue reading... about Careers

      • Job Openings
      • Submit Resume
      • Make Enquiry
  • Focus Group Facility
    • Viewing Facility
    • Live Streaming
  • Contact Us

Texas Supreme Court Upholds Legitimacy of Survey Research for Trials: IA Helps Court Evaluate Supposed “Push Poll”

The Texas Supreme Court rejected a lower court’s order against a law firm for a supposed “push poll” in what the Insights Association called “a crucial victory for the right of litigants to use bona fide marketing research in court trials.”

The Insights Association, the leading nonprofit trade association for the marketing research and data analytics industry, had filed amicus briefs in the Texas Supreme Court, as well in the lower court of appeals in 2016, in defense of research in this case.

The case (Brewer v. Lennox Hearth Products LLC et al., case # 18-0426) was a further appeal of sanctions that were levied against Brewer, Attorneys & Counselors, a law firm defending a company in a complicated high-profile personal injury suit. The sanctioning was primarily based on a survey that sought to test public opinions on themes and views of the case before trial. A lower court judge ruled that the survey was a “push poll” and sanctioned the law firm for breaching legal ethics.

According to the majority decision, “the evidence shows [Brewer] undertook reasonable efforts to secure a third-party industry professional to create a relatively balanced public opinion survey for random administration. The record bears no direct, or even circumstantial, evidence of bad faith.”

The decision noted that, “Pretrial surveys are not uncommon and are neither categorically permissible nor inherently suspect.” Case law, the decision continued, shows “[e]xamples of pretrial surveys… from almost every state and in the federal judicial system. Such surveys are not inherently improper.” Further, it found no reason to suspect the integrity of the research process in this case: “the evidence shows he undertook reasonable efforts to secure a third-party industry professional to create a relatively balanced public opinion survey for random administration. The record bears no direct, or even circumstantial, evidence of bad faith.”

The Texas Supreme Court concluded that, “Evidence that the survey database and survey respondents were randomly selected—without any input by Brewer or his staff—was unrefuted. And the record does not support the allegation that anyone in particular was ‘targeted.’ Nor is there evidence that the size of the survey database suggested anything untoward. Genuine inaccuracies in the formulation of litigation statements tested in Brewer’s quite lengthy survey are debatable, but any such defects were isolated and few and far between. The survey reflects reasonable efforts to achieve a reasonable degree of balance.”

In response to the court win, Howard Fienberg, VP Advocacy of the Insights Association, commented that “the decision not only prevented the chilling of marketing research in the context of litigation and jury trials, but also vindicated bona fide research conducted by legitimate companies under the strictures of the insights industry’s codes and standards.”

Read the full majority decision here.

Photo credit to Noé Alfaro.

NewsGovernment AffairsHoward Fienberg, CAE – The Insights Association

Share to: LinkedIn Twitter Google Plus Facebook 

PDF icon majority_opinion.pdf

April 30, 2020 By howard.fienberg

RDR

Random Dynamic Resources Ltd

Some of Our Clients

  • mmr
  • ipsos
  • visioncritical
  • gfk
  • nielsen
  • ifis
  • clearpath
  • pepsi
  • nexim
  • samsung
  • tns
  • ask-afrika
  • cola
  • mindlab
  • airtel
  • dialego

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

News Update

  • E-Tabs Launches Enterprise Cloud

    January 17, 2022

  • Letter from WAPOR President (January 2022)

    January 11, 2022

  • IPC Q&A: Tim Kunkel of Suzy

    January 11, 2022

  • Aksel Bedikyan Named Vice President of Leger Analytics

    January 11, 2022

  • In Memoriam: Naomi Henderson, Founder & CEO of RIVA

    January 11, 2022

  • InSites Consulting Acquires Gongos, Inc.

    January 11, 2022

  • New Director Robert Santos Takes Over U.S. Census Bureau

    January 07, 2022

  • Opposing Expanded FTC Enforcement Power in the Build Back Better Act

    December 23, 2021

  • Labor Market Competition and Non-Compete Agreements

    December 22, 2021

  • IA Announces 2022 Events Calendar

    December 20, 2021

  • Smarty Pants Adds Davison to Team

    December 20, 2021

  • Dynata Acquires Optimus Analytics

    December 15, 2021

  • CIRQ Announces ISO 27001 Certification of P\S\L Group

    December 15, 2021

  • Resolutions and Revolutions for the New Year

    December 15, 2021

  • CIRQ Announces ISO 27001 Certification of P\S\L Group

    December 09, 2021



read more...

RDR in just 2 minutes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1o9Vt934FA&sns=fb

Stay informed

The Core of Market Research In Africa

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Npc6UbUg4s

Footer

Key Sectors

  • ICT & Telecom
  • FMCG
  • Automobile
  • Manufacturing
  • Pharmaceutical
  • Financial Services
  • International Development and social Research

Our Expertise

  • Qualitative
  • Quantitative

Get In Touch

  • Contact Us
  • Join Random Dynamic Resources

We are corporate member of

  • esomar1
  • insight-association
  • pamro
  • World Association for Public Opinion Research
  • American-Association-for-Public-Opinion-Research
  • Nigeria-Marketing-Research-Association
  • International Trade Council

Copyright © 2022|. Random Dynamic Resources Ltd. All rights reserved.